Katama Kitchen At The Right Fork On Martha’s Vineyard

I felt like I would not be able to love anything but the iconic Right Fork Diner at the Katama Airport. However, I was mistaken, Katama Kitchen has taken me on a flight of fancy with what it has to offer.

What do I like the most? The evidence of love of all things planes is really charming. There are planes that people own etched into the tables. There is a nod to the airports of the places that have inspired the items on the menu, and of course, you still get to enjoy planes taking off and arriving at Katana Airfield. It continues to feel like a special Island experience.

Katama Kitchen At The Right Fork On Martha’s Vineyard New Dining Out In Katama Summer 2021 Point B Realty On Point Blog
The Katama Kitchen Team

Katama Kitchen At The Right Fork On Martha’s Vineyard – The Family Behind The New Restaurant

Evan Shai, one of the owners is a pilot. He and his wife Jessica fly as often as they can. A day trip to Nantucket, a quick jaunt to Hyannis, as long as he gets to the sky. Katama Kitchen is the perfect way to combine his love of planes and working with his family in the restaurant scene on Martha’s Vineyard. It’s a family affair here. Zared, Evan’s brother, has also recently gotten his pilot’s license as well.

Katama Kitchen At The Right Fork On Martha’s Vineyard Outdoor Dining 
Visit Edgartown
Martha's Vineyard 
New for Summer 2021
Point B Realty
The Deck at Katama Kitchen

Katama Kitchen At The Right Fork On Martha’s Vineyard – Breakfast And Lunch

As of now, Katama Kitchen is open for Breakfast and lunch, 7:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. For breakfast, a.k.a “Pre-Flight,” you will find some classics like pancakes, benedicts, omelettes, and breakfast sandwiches along with items like the Tater Bowl. I love tater tots for breakfast (lunch and dinner). This dish has tots, cheese gravy, sausage, and chives – YUM!

Katama Kitchen
Visit Edgartown
Martha's Vineyard 
New for Summer 2021
Point B Realty
A Cessna from Katama

We went for lunch, a.k.a “Cruising Altitude.” You will find a great selection of lunch sandwiches. There’s a cheesesteak, Cubano, Muffuletta, burgers, and more. There are also salads and soups too. It’s a perfect place to enjoy lunch with the menu they’ve created.

I ordered the Cubano which had ham, roasted pork, Swiss, pickles, mustard and Cuban bread. Inspired by MIA – Miami, Florida, Elevation: 9’ATIS 119.15. It was a delicious Cubano, and definitely one of my go to sandwiches. There is something about this combination that is just irresistible.

Katama Kitchen
Cubano
Cuban inspired sandwich
Visit Edgartown
Martha's Vineyard 
New for Summer 2021
Point B Realty
The Cubano at Katama Kitchen

My friend Leah got the Vermonter, RUT- Rutland, VT, Elevation: 787′ AWOS 118.375. This sandwich was piled high with maple turkey, Vermont cheddar, green apple, honey and mustard on rye. She really enjoyed her sandwich as well. Vermont cheddar makes it better — right?

Katama Kitchen
Outdoor Dining 
Visit Edgartown
Martha's Vineyard 
New for Summer 2021
Point B Realty
That Outdoor Dining Space Makes You Smile

We did get greens for the side, but could not resist an order of yummy tater tots to complete our meal. We both agreed that we have to come back for breakfast ASAP!

Katama Kitchen
Visit Edgartown
Martha's Vineyard 
New for Summer 2021
Point B Realty
Tater Tots are Always a Good Idea

Katama Kitchen At The Right Fork On Martha’s Vineyard – Atmosphere

Katama Kitchen has a really great atmosphere. It feels relaxed and light and airy. Sitting outside on the deck is pretty magical, an experience all in its self. We watched Classic Aviator’s bi-planes taking off and landing, along with other planes while we ate and chatted. The sun was shining, a light breeze blowing. It was one of those perfect summer afternoons where time just slipped away.

Katama Kitchen
Takeout 
Visit Edgartown
Martha's Vineyard 
New for Summer 2021
Point B Realty
Takeout is a Popular Option at Katama Kitchen

Katama Kitchen At The Right Fork On Martha’s Vineyard – Dinner And Takeout

The Shai family does have plans to offer dinner in the summer, take-off date to be determined. Also, there are plans to have a full liquor license. An added bonus since I do enjoy a mimosa with breakfast while watching planes take off to new adventures. Don’t forget about takeout as an option, and dining inside is pretty awesome too with the new addition of booths (always a favorite).

Visit Edgartown
Martha's Vineyard 
New for Summer 2021
Point B Realty
We Love the Booths at Katama Kitchen

In addition to the great space, the staff is friendly, the new chef, Ben Herriman, is excited to be part of the Katama Kitchen team, and cook great food for guests. This new Shai family adventure is one to watch and celebrate being a part of (The Shai brothers also own Dos Mas in Oak Bluffs and Taco MV in Edgartown). There is a special joy when you work with those you love doing what you love.

Let’s kick the tires and light the fires” — Famously uttered by Harry Connick Jr. in Independence Day, and try the new Katama Kitchen this summer.

To learn more about Bi-Plane rides with Classic Aviators, check out our Martha’s Vineyard Bucket List: Biplane Rides Over Martha’s Vineyard.

Katama Kitchen
Classic Aviators
Visit Edgartown
Martha's Vineyard 
Vineyard Bucket List 
Point B Realty
Classic Aviators – a Vineyard Icon

Thanks for reading On Point MV. Also be sure to check out We Love MV  our ON POINT MV Blog series capturing the spirit of Martha’s Vineyard year-round. We hope you are staying safe during these times. Please don’t forget to “Like” Point B Realty on Facebook, and follow us on TwitterLinked InPinterestYoutube and Instagram.

4 thoughts on “Katama Kitchen At The Right Fork On Martha’s Vineyard”

  1. That’s great news, Guinevere! Can’t wait to try it later this summer. I’ll be celebrating my 40th consecutive summer on MVY.

  2. You couldn’t have gotten it more wrong about Katama Kitchen. We were there this week, and the service was absolutely horrid. We waited over 25 minutes just to have our order taken, and this was with open tables all around us. Our food arrived almost 60 minutes later: A Cubano that tasted like cardboard, a Vermonter that was bland, and a Philly cheesesteak that was neither Philly or steak. Wow, how the mighty have fallen. We used to love the Right Fork diner. This new diner should be grounded.

    1. Hi Jennifer –

      I am so sorry that you had an unpleasant experience at Katama Kitchen. I hope that this does not happen again. I imagine that there are some growing pains with a new restaurant and labor shortage.

      Best,
      Guin

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.