Oak Bluffs Fish Market Celebrates Its Second Year: Lobster Rolls, Chowder And More On Martha’s Vineyard

Last year, I was so excited to write about the opening of the Oak Bluffs Fish Market. This addition to town, now makes OB a one-stop shopping destination. With Reliable Market (meats and groceries) and a couple of package stores, and the fish market, it’s all within a three block radius. Perfect for easy Summer living or entertaining.

Oak Bluffs Fish Market Martha's Vineyard

A New Partnership

You might notice some new things when you visit the Oak Bluffs Fish Market. For starters, you’ll probably find new co-owner, Mike Holtham behind the counter. He has partnered with Sandy Fisher to help grow the market. Mike has a lot to offer.

Oak Bluffs Fish Market New Owner Mike Holtham

Thinking that name sounds familiar? Well, this Islander has some pedigree. He has grown up in the restaurant business here. His family once owned the Homeport restaurant, and he has worked in several notable Island foodie spots, like Offshore Ale and State Road.

Oak Bluffs Fish Market Martha's Vineyard

He also worked for the Menemsha Fish House for four years, really helping get the business going, which now serves as the premier water-to-table seafood provider for local fishermen and restaurants. Within those for years, he really honed his customer service skills and his knowledge of fish — both local and what’s available from the Boston markets.

You need something a little more unique, like caviar? Mike is your man. He is your resource for special order seafood needs.

Oak Bluffs Fish Market

However, he is most excited to offer a selection of local fish. With his relationships from Menemsha, he is able to get amazing local fish. Vineyard Bluefish and Scup, Chappy Oysters and Cottage City Oysters, are just a couple of the local offerings.

steamersThe Oak Bluffs Fish Market has also become a great resource for restaurants in town. Having someone so knowledgable about the fish business and the restaurant business is a great combination. He can really work with chefs to get what they want and need.


The Oak Bluffs Fish Market is now a good option for takeaway. At the moment, you can grab a lobster roll ($15), chowder, shrimp cocktail, and local oysters if you’re looking for a fresh, seafood inspired bite to eat.

Oak Bluffs Fish Market Food To Go Takeout Fish Raw Bar Martha's VineyardIn July,  there will be sushi added to the takeout options. Sand Bar Restaurant is right next door, and has some pretty good sushi options. It would be great to have something like that available to grab to take to the beach for a light lunch or dinner.


Fresh Tuns & Swordfish Oak Bluffs Fish Market Martha's Vineyard

Mike and Sandy are also planning to offer steamed lobster dinners as an option later this Summer. Once again, a great way to make entertaining or beach dinners easier. Grab your lobsters and oysters from Oak Bluffs Fish Market, your beverages from Jim’s Package Store (right Next store), some sweet treats from the Sweet Spot (Dockside Market), and you’re set.

The Holtham Family New Owners Of Oak Bluffs Fish Market Martha's Vineyard

Mike is excited to be the local fish guy in OB. In January, when Sandy approached him about a partnership, he knew it would be a good fit. With his love of fish, and the fact that he has always wanted to own a business, this was an opportunity not to miss, almost tailor made. He is excited to create a legacy with his family, wife Jessie and their daughter, Jolene.

The Oak Bluffs Fish Market is a small, family run business that offers the freshest fish, and strives for incredible customer service.

Oak Bluffs Fish market

The Oak Bluffs Fish Market is conveniently located on Circuit Ave Extension, next to Jim’s Package Store and the Sand Bar. Spring hours are daily 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. In July and August, the hours will be 9 a.m. to 7 p.m. You can even call ahead and have your order waiting for you.

You can learn more about the Oak Bluffs Fish Market on Facebook. And don’t forget to “Like” us on Facebook, and follow us on Twitter, Linked In, Google+, Pinterest and Youtube.

1 thought on “Oak Bluffs Fish Market Celebrates Its Second Year: Lobster Rolls, Chowder And More On Martha’s Vineyard”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *